Were you wearing shorts at the time? ;-)
Martin
Could it be that one of the 4051 is not correctly desactivated? So two 4051s are active at the same time and the voltages from the pots are added up?
Which pin of the 4051 did you check?
@dubtoms
The Idea is that from somewhere some Voltage is leaking either directly into the CV Rail on the PCB (thats the one leading to the CV1 Pin greenish in the Pic) or in the Select Lines from the 4051s (violet).

You may Check this by turning all Pots to 0 and then trying on pot after another. Only the pots value should change, if you got one that changes more than Parameter thats the suspicious point. Check that first, it only takes a Minute…
For the possible problem that a CV is leaking into the 4051 select lines the yellow circled Spot is the most suspicious Area. Test here: disconnect Programmer and measure Resistance between CV Rail (greenish) and the violet Select Lines (best at Pin 6 of every 4051). There should be no connection whatsoever between the Lines.
If everyone that goes to Paris gets to visit with pichenettes and solder up a few boards, I’m buying a ticket now…
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!